Four U.S. bank and credit union regulators have proposed replacing their 2023 third-party risk guidance with a shorter, principles-based text, and on 13 November they gave the industry until 16 December to comment. The proposal reaches every vendor a bank depends on, from the core processor to the fintech that distributes its deposit accounts, and one Federal Reserve governor has already dissented.
The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, the Federal Reserve Board, the National Credit Union Administration and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency requested comment on 11 September. The comment period was due to close on 16 November. The agencies extended it to 16 December, and the Fed did the same for its separate guide for community banks.
This feature goes through the primary documents: the agencies’ release, the Federal Register notice, the joint statement on core providers, the Board staff memo that asked for approval to publish, and the statements of two Board members who voted differently.
What the agencies put out for comment
Three documents came out together on 11 September, according to the agencies’ release.
- Interagency guidance on third-party relationships. It applies to all banks and credit unions. It is principles-based and, like all supervisory guidance, non-binding. When finalized, the agencies plan to rescind their existing third-party risk guidance and replace it with this text.
- A Federal Reserve guide for traditional community banks. The Board’s staff memo defines these as banking organizations with less than $30 billion in assets that focus on serving their local communities. It is a companion to the interagency text and applies only to Board-regulated banks.
- A joint statement on community banks and core service providers. It comes from the Board, the FDIC and the OCC and sets out what supervisors will weigh when deciding how closely to examine a core provider.
The Federal Register notice, published on 15 September, put the original comment deadline at 16 November. If the guidance is finalized as proposed, it replaces three existing documents, according to the notice and the Board staff memo of 28 August: the 2023 interagency guidance, the 2024 community bank guide, and the July 2024 joint statement on banks’ arrangements with third parties to deliver bank deposit products and services. The notice describes that last document as a statement on bank-fintech arrangements.
The Fed’s community bank guide has two parts, according to the staff memo. The first covers four priority topics: operational resilience, system and information security, compliance with rules and regulations, and financial resilience. The second covers eight categories of third parties that smaller banks use: core service providers, IT infrastructure providers, cybersecurity providers, payment processing and digital banking providers, loan management system providers, card issuing and processing providers, Bank Secrecy Act and anti-money laundering platform providers, and fraud prevention and detection providers. Consumer compliance is outside the guide.
Why the agencies want to replace the 2023 guidance
The Federal Register notice gives the agencies’ reasoning. They continue to believe the principles-based approach of the 2023 text is relevant, but they say it has been read too broadly and with too little focus on tailoring. The notice names five problems.
- Banks struggled to tell which of the long list of considerations applied to which relationship, and the detailed examples read like a checklist.
- The 2023 text focuses on the activity a third party performs rather than on the size and likelihood of harm from the relationship.
- Words such as “should” in the examples were taken as requirements.
- The text unintentionally rewarded process-driven approaches that spread effort away from the higher-risk relationships.
- The text has been read to discourage arrangements with newer and innovative third parties.
On the last point the agencies tie their proposal to Executive Order 14405 on integrating financial technology innovation into regulatory frameworks, which the notice cites at 91 FR 30475 (19 May 2026). The notice says the proposal would remove broad-based and overly prescriptive language that may unduly impede fintechs from entering partnerships with banking organizations.
How the proposal tells banks to rank their vendors
The proposal organizes third-party risk management into four components: identifying and assessing risks, overseeing them in proportion to their significance, deciding how much residual risk to accept, and governance. Each one pushes banks toward tailoring.
Risk assessment weighs harm and likelihood
Banks are asked to weigh both the magnitude of harm a relationship could cause and the likelihood that it occurs. The notice expects most banks to rate core processing relationships as higher risk. It also says a bank can reasonably rate the same type of relationship differently depending on how much of its business runs through it.
The text lists the third parties that sit closest to a bank’s operations: core processors, providers of cloud processing, cloud storage and compliance tools, and fintechs that partner with banks to provide access to financial services. Facilities, clerical and office-support vendors sit at the other end.
Lower-risk vendors get lighter treatment
For lower-risk relationships, a bank may rely on less detailed due diligence, use public or alternative sources of information, accept a standard-form contract and monitor less often. The notice says the absence of a particular contract term, even one an examiner considers a best practice, is not by itself a sufficient basis for an adverse finding about a bank’s third-party risk management.
Limited bargaining power is a recognized fact
The text accepts that a bank may be unable to negotiate every provision it wants. It may still proceed if it understands the risks and the residual risk sits within its stated appetite. It also states that the agencies do not expect banks to eliminate third-party risk. One limit stays in place: where a third party is unable or unwilling to give the bank the information it reasonably needs for due diligence and monitoring, outside sources may not be enough to justify the relationship.
Banks may pool their work
The guidance names co-ventures and consortia that perform joint due diligence or develop standard contracts, and certification bodies that assess third parties against published standards. A bank may find summaries and certifications from these arrangements adequate for its due diligence, depending on the facts. The bank still has to judge the results against its own performance criteria.
The core provider statement turns to contract terms
The joint statement from the Board, the FDIC and the OCC is aimed at the vendor side of the table. It calls core providers the most material, complex and highest-risk third-party relationships of a community bank. It also says a significant share of the core market sits with a few large providers, which limits what banks can negotiate. Banks report trouble getting due diligence information, negotiating terms and monitoring these providers.
The agencies say they will weigh three sets of factors when deciding how to allocate supervisory attention to a core provider: how often and how closely to examine it, what goes into the examination reports shared with client banks, and whether to add it to the service provider examination program.
- Transparency. Willingness to hand over timely due diligence information, contract terms that limit a bank’s ability to compare offerings, service level agreements with measurable standards, prompt disclosure of operational issues and security incidents, and billing that cannot be reconciled to the services delivered.
- Contract features. Opaque pricing, extensive “back billing” windows for retroactive charges, undefined or unsupported deconversion fees, and excessive limits on unaffiliated providers integrating with the core platform.
- Technology. The number and severity of computer security incidents, how end-of-support and end-of-life assets are managed, and the absence of demonstrated operational resilience.
The statement also says the agencies may bring supervisory and enforcement actions against core providers or the bank where unsafe or unsound practices or violations of law arise. A guest opinion piece we published from a sourcing adviser, Financial Institutions Are Willing to Switch Vendors, but Their Contracts Aren’t Ready, makes the buyer-side case on core provider contracts.
Where fintech partnerships sit
The fintech detail is the most contested part of the package. The staff memo says the community bank guide is not intended for organizations with more complex business models or third-party relationship profiles, “such as complex bank-fintech partnerships,” where the fintech rather than the bank markets or distributes the product. The interagency text would then replace the 2024 joint statement on deposit-product arrangements.
Two Board members read that design in opposite ways.
Governor Barr dissented
Michael S. Barr, a Federal Reserve Governor, said he could support a principles-based approach but dissented. In his statement he wrote: “I am concerned that this proposal will reduce safe and sound operations, increase financial and other risk, create undue confusion, and leave gaps in supervisory coverage.”
He pointed to several features. The guidance introduces a standard of “material financial risk” for supervisors to take action, which he says makes it less likely that banks correct problems before they grow. The phrase on due consideration of a bank’s reasonable decisions could be read as deference to the bank’s own view. Both proposals exclude consumer compliance matters, and he says a final text could end up rescinding existing guidance or leaving banks with two sets of guidance to follow. On bank-fintech arrangements he wrote: “Experience suggests that many banks with complex business models are especially in need of guidance that better addresses their particular third-party risk management issues, which is not addressed in these proposals.”
Governor Cook supported the direction and asked for more detail
Lisa D. Cook, also a Federal Reserve Governor, supported taking a fresh look at the guidance and called the community bank guide “a tailored, helpful resource to assist traditional community banks” and asked industry for input on the bank-fintech question. In her statement she wrote: “I welcome comments on whether the agencies should provide greater specificity on effective risk management practices relating to cybersecurity or the allocation of responsibilities for consumer protection, record management, and anti-money laundering in bank-fintech partnerships.”
Cook’s request is an open invitation to the people who run those partnerships. The topics she lists, cybersecurity, consumer protection, record management and anti-money laundering, are the ones that sponsor banks and fintechs split by contract today.
What it means for the finance leader
A finance leader at a bank, a credit union or a fintech that sells to either will see the effects in vendor conversations before any final text appears. The proposal is not binding, but it tells examiners and banks what to weigh.
If you buy from banks or sponsor-bank partners
Expect your bank’s vendor oversight to sort you by risk. A provider that sits on critical activity, or a fintech that distributes the bank’s products, will keep facing detailed requests. A provider on the low-risk end may get standard-form contracts and lighter monitoring. Prepare the evidence a bank can reuse: independent assessments, incident history and a clear account of subcontractors. The proposal says oversight of subcontractors depends on the nature and risks of the relationship, and the bank stays responsible for compliance regardless of who performs the work.
Our recent piece on UK regulators’ joint cyber resilience guidance shows the same direction abroad, with controls over third parties and supply chains listed as a protection requirement.
If you run a core, payments or card platform
The three core provider factors read like a contract checklist: pricing, billing windows, deconversion fees, service level data, incident disclosure and openness to outside integrations. The statement does not set caps or ban any term. It says these practices will count when supervisors decide how closely to examine a provider. Check your standard terms against that list before banks do.
If you hold a bank partnership
The Board’s own guide leaves complex bank-fintech arrangements outside its scope, and the proposed interagency text replaces the 2024 joint statement. Barr and Cook both name the topic, and the comment period runs to 16 December. In our reading, a fintech with a sponsor-bank relationship has a direct reason to file a comment now, because the agencies asked for views on whether more specificity is needed and Cook listed the exact topics.
What to watch
The comment deadline is 16 December 2026. The extension release gives no date for the final text and says only that the agencies plan to rescind the existing guidance once the new text is finalized. The Fed’s community bank guide faces the same 16 December deadline. Three questions remain open: whether the final text keeps the “material financial risk” standard Barr objects to, whether it says more about bank-fintech arrangements, and whether the core provider factors turn into examination practice.


