The Commodity Futures Trading Commission will spend three hours on December 15 asking whether derivatives markets can trade around the clock. I think the middle hour decides the answer. A matching engine can run all weekend; the question that settles whether it should is whether margin can move while it does.
The agenda puts margin in the middle
On November 17 the CFTC released the agenda (a linked PDF) for the roundtable, which it first announced on October 28. The agenda has three sessions. The first asks which asset classes are ready for 24/7 trading now, in one to two years, later or never. The third covers price discovery, volatility controls such as position limits and circuit breakers, staffing, and cybersecurity.
The second session is titled Risk Management Needs for 24/7 Clearing, and its first topic is access to capital and clearing, collateral and margin. It then asks how tokenization, stablecoin adoption and other emerging technology can address current roadblocks to 24/7 clearing, and what risks may arise from pre-funded models and separate weekend trading sessions.
Chairman Michael S. Selig framed the purpose in the release: “I look forward to hearing directly from industry stakeholders on the ways 24/7 trading would impact their respective business models to ensure the Commission is appropriately tailoring its regulatory regime for all market participants.” That is a fair way to run a roundtable. It also means the session that decides how far the regime can stretch will be the one where participants describe their weekend money movement in detail.
Why clearing hours set trading hours
A clearinghouse that lets members trade at 3 a.m. on a Sunday takes on exposure it must be able to margin. Variation margin has to be called, and the call has to be met, in cash or collateral that is accepted and movable at that hour. If the answer is that margin waits until Monday, the exchange has extended its opening hours and left its risk controls on the old calendar.
The CFTC has already shown how small the plumbing changes can look. On November 5 its Division of Clearing and Risk issued a no-action letter saying a derivatives clearing organization may use a trust company for daily settlements if it “treats the trust company as it would a settlement bank”. The letter responded to Nodal Clear, which argued that the change would let clearinghouses accept digital assets as margin collateral inside their existing daily workflows. We covered the letter in CFTC Staff Says Clearinghouses May Use Trust Companies for Daily Settlement. A staff letter on one defined term widened who can sit in the settlement chain, and it shows how much of the weekend question sits in definitions written for a weekday market.
The private sector is moving on the same front. Our report Talos, Marex and Broadridge Plan Off-Hours Financing of DTCC-Tokenized Treasuries covers a plan to finance tokenized Treasuries outside market hours. Firms are planning off-hours collateral work now, and a regulator weighing 24/7 trading can ask them what it takes.
The counter-argument and my answer
The strongest objection is that pre-funding solves the problem. If every participant posts enough collateral up front to cover a weekend, no one needs a Saturday margin call, and a separate weekend session can run with the cash already in place. The agenda lists it as a model to examine.
My answer is that pre-funding moves the cost to the participant and leaves the risk where it was. The agenda asks what risks may arise from pre-funded models, and that question has to be answered with numbers: how much extra collateral a member must hold for a weekend, who holds it, and where it sits when prices gap on a Sunday night.
What the roundtable should ask for
Before December 15 the CFTC should ask every clearinghouse and clearing member on the panels for one document: the hours at which each step of margin runs today, from the margin call to the settlement-bank confirmation to the collateral release, with the weekend hours marked. A calendar of that kind turns Session Two from a discussion of principles into a list of gaps that can be counted. Selig has said the CFTC will take no one-size-fits-all approach to 24/7 trading, and asset classes will sort themselves by who can show a complete weekend calendar.
That test favours products whose clearing chain already runs at the weekend and exposes those whose chain does not. It is also the cheapest test to apply, since every clearing member already knows its own hours.
Source: CFTC
Source: CFTC
